July 9, 2015
Dear friends in Christ,
The 78th General Convention of the Episcopal Church has authorized for trial use, beginning the first Sunday in Advent, 2015, two liturgies related to same-sex marriage contained in Liturgical Resources I: I Will Bless You and You Will Be a Blessing, Revised and Expanded 2015. While these are to be used only "under the direction and with the permission of the diocesan bishop," the empowering resolution further requires that the bishop "make provision for all couples to have access" to these rites.
Here is what this means for us in Pittsburgh. Any couple who wishes to make use of these rites should begin the way couples have always begun: by approaching their rector or priest-in-charge. If the rector or priest-in-charge is willing to use them, no consultation with me is necessary. Should any rector or priest-in-charge be unwilling, for any reason, to use these rites, he or she will contact the rector or priest-in-charge of another parish who would be willing to do so and, together with the couple, work out a way forward that protects the consciences of all concerned and does not impose an undue burden on any. In such a case, I ask the clergy involved to contact me from the beginning to keep me informed. We have already followed this process for the use of the provisional rite, and I am aware of no instance in which everyone involved has not quickly arrived at a happy arrangement. However, should the parties be unable to come to a resolution on their own, I will help them find an expedient alternative.
These rites will provide all couples clear security in the eyes of the law, and equal dignity in the eyes of their church. However, to my mind, their supporting materials do not make a coherent or compelling theological case for same-sex marriage, nor do the rites themselves adequately explain what they are doing and why. Especially in the wake of the recent Supreme Court decision, their approval was seen by the overwhelming majority of those present at Convention as a matter of"marriage equality," of simple justice, making irrelevant any serious discussion of sacramental theology. Nonetheless, this is a conversation that very much needs to happen, on the ground, in the pastoral context of people's lives and hopes; perhaps as our pastors and people consider the use of these rites, we can find ways to have such a discussion together.
As always, I call us to hold our unity in Christ as a precious gift. The House of Bishops, especially over the last days of Convention, demonstrated remarkable graciousness in embracing one another in love while maintaining both the depth of our personal convictions and the clarity of our differences. I hope and trust we will do the same in our own diocese. To that end, please be assured of my continuing prayers, as I ask you to pray for me.
Faithfully your bishop,
(The Rt. Rev.) Dorsey McConnell
Editor's Note: The two new liturgies will not be published for distribution until Fall 2015 and are not authorized for use before November 29, 2015. They can be previewed on pgs. 87-105 of the Supplemental Report of the Standing Commission on Liturgy and Music as amended by General Convention Resolution A054. More on the House of Bishops action at the end of Convention can be found here.